Understanding the burden of proof and its importance in civil cases is important if you’re thinking about filing a personal injury case. If the burden of proof is on your side, the law compels you to provide evidence to support your claim.
As is typical in civil cases, the burden of proof is on the person making a claim (known as the plaintiff). Witness testimony, physical items, and documentation are the most common types of proof. During a trial, the judge divides the burden of proof among the participants.
Both the judge and jury determine whether the plaintiff proved the claim and the implications of success or failure. A personal injury attorney in Texas can help you understand your legal rights and compensation.
When Is a Burden of Proof Required?
Suppose you assert that your solution to a problem is superior to others. In that case, you have the burden to prove and justify why your approach is superior. The burden of proof also applies in philosophical debate claims, when one side may accuse the other of using faulty reasoning; in this case, the accuser must provide evidence to support their allegation.
Most legal proceedings need the burden of proof, and this includes:
- Cases regarding civil matters
- Court cases involving criminal activity
- Cases in family court
The court will not automatically side with one party in these situations. In a legal proceeding, however, the burden of proof is on the party asserting the claim. If your argument is accepted, the burden of proof shifts to the other side.
In other words, if you get into a community property dispute and claim, “This property belongs to me,” the court will not accept your claim unless you can back it up with documentation, such as dates or documents of buying or selling. Similarly, the injured party in a vehicle accident must establish that the other driver’s carelessness caused their injuries.
The Burden of Proof in a Civil Case Differs From a Criminal Case in Texas
The person or entity who starts the civil action has the burden of proof. It is up to the person who is suing to prove that the accusations are true and that the defendant caused the losses.
In civil cases, it is usually your job to prove the case if you are the one accusing. In some civil disputes, you may need to show evidence that is either clear and convincing or has a high chance of being true.
On the other hand, a person accused of a crime is thought to be innocent until they are proven guilty. Most of the time, it is up to the prosecution to prove their case and the guilt of the defendant beyond a reasonable doubt, while it is up to the accused to prove their innocence.
In general, the burden of proof is your responsibility if you are the one accusing. As a general rule, the law doesn’t put this burden of proof on the person being accused. Remember that in the burden of proof, the quality of the evidence is just as important as the amount of evidence.
What Are the Three Burdens of Proof?
Plaintiffs in civil cases in Texas must meet the burden of proof according to a legal standard. The bigger the stakes, the more difficult it is to prove the claim. When it comes to legal processes, here are the most common proves to help make a strong case:
Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
In criminal trials, this is the highest standard of proof. It simply points to eliminating any reasonable doubts about the reality of the incident. To prove the claim beyond a reasonable doubt is to demonstrate that there is no other possible explanation for the defendant’s actions other than those presented in court.
Proof According to a Preponderance of Evidence
A simple definition is that something is more likely true than false. If a court must decide based on the greater weight of the evidence, the judge will rule that a certain fact is more true than false. Plaintiffs must show that the accused is more than 50% liable for damages to prevail in a civil case.
Proof by Clear and Convincing Evidence
A person must provide evidence to prove the integrity of a fact or disputed issue with “reasonable certainty.” The evidence must be convincing enough to inspire a “concrete trust,” another way of putting it. The burden of proof increases from that of a simple majority to that of absolute certainty.
Essential Elements of a Negligence Argument in a Civil Case
To win a negligence case, you must prove that the defendant owed you a duty of care and broke it. A key part of a successful defense is showing that the defendant did something unusual or wrong.
Following this, you’ll need to provide evidence that this caused your harm. If you want to know where you stand legally and what the conclusion of your case is likely, you must understand the burden of proof.
How Can a Texas Personal Injury Attorney Help Me Meet the Burden of Proof?
You can hire a personal injury lawyer in Texas to handle your claim for damages or civil cases. They know the kind of proof, the documents required, and more. They’ll figure out what your compensation would look like and research to build a strong case.
Discuss Your Case to Know Your Legal Rights and Responsibilities
The burden of proof is the level of proof needed to win a case in court. Contact our personal injury lawyers in Texas if you are wondering how the burden of proof can hurt or help your case.
We at the Buzbee Law Firm can help you with case specifics and different types of litigation. Talk to our representative to understand the burden of proof and why it is essential to your case.